Bloodgood vs Crimson Queen Japanese Maple: Which One to Plant?

Bloodgood vs Crimson Queen Japanese Maple: Which One to Plant?

Most people pick a red Japanese maple by the photo on the tag, and that is where it goes wrong. A Bloodgood pushed into a five-foot gap beside the house needs cutting back every year. A Crimson Queen bought for height never gets it, and ends up as a low dome. Both are red, but they are different trees, and the one you choose will stand in that spot for decades.

Bloodgood Japanese Maple nursery tree
Bloodgood Japanese Maple Nursery-grown Bloodgood Japanese Maple, shipped to your door. Sizes from QT Container. From $49.49.
Shop Now →

The color is close enough that form and size should decide it. In this article, we'll go through the shape of each tree, how the leaves and color compare, how big each one really gets, and what each needs to stay healthy. We also tell you which one we'd plant for most yards, and for whom the other is the better call.

Bloodgood vs Crimson Queen: The Difference in Form

The biggest split between these two starts with their basic structure.

Bloodgood is an upright, vase-shaped tree. Its branches grow outward and slightly upward, creating a tidy, architectural silhouette. This is the classic Japanese maple form that most home gardeners picture when they think of the plant. The trunk is visible from nearly every angle, and the branching structure remains tight and controlled even as the tree matures.

Crimson Queen is a dissectum or weeping cultivar. Its branches are pendulous, meaning they grow downward and drape gracefully toward the ground. The overall shape is more of a mounding or fountain-like form, especially when young. As it ages, the branches can weep so dramatically that they touch or sweep across the soil.

This single difference shapes almost everything else: your spacing decisions, pruning needs, and how the tree reads in your landscape.

Customers often ask us whether a Crimson Queen can be trained upright if the space is tight. It can't, not without fighting its nature every year, so choose the form you want to see from the start.

Foliage and Color

Both Bloodgood and Crimson Queen display deep red to burgundy foliage throughout the growing season, which is why they're both prized for year-round color. But the shape of that foliage is strikingly different. Some maples bring winter color through coral bark instead of leaves.

Bloodgood leaves are palmate with 5 to 7 lobes, giving them a broader, more familiar maple appearance. They're roughly hand-sized and hold their deep reddish-purple color well into fall, when they shift to crimson and bright red before dropping.

Crimson Queen leaves are finely cut and lacy. The foliage is so dissected that it almost looks feathery at a distance. This fine texture is one of its signature features. The color is equally vibrant but the leaf structure gives the whole tree a softer, more ornamental, almost ethereal quality compared to Bloodgood's bolder presence.

Both keep their red better than many Japanese maples, but light still matters. In deep shade, Bloodgood fades toward a dull bronze-green, so we don't follow the common advice to tuck red maples into full shade. Bloodgood does well in full sun to partial shade. What we tell customers is to give it morning sun and afternoon shade where summers are hot, which prevents leaf scorch. Other red maples handle strong sun differently, so the choice matters in hot yards.

Size and Growth Rate

This is where you need to pay close attention to your available space.

Bloodgood is a larger tree than many buyers expect. In US yards we usually see 12 to 20 feet, with a spread of 15 to 20 feet on older trees. The species itself runs taller, so a Bloodgood stays smaller than a seedling Japanese maple.

Growth is slow to moderate, as it is for the species as a whole, so it takes years to fill its footprint. Space it well away from structures and other large trees, because the branching structure needs room to develop.

Crimson Queen is a smaller tree overall. It usually stays around 8 to 12 feet tall and spreads about 10 to 15 feet wide, though this varies with climate and care. The weeping habit makes it look even more compact, and the arching branches form an umbrella that is less imposing than an upright tree of the same height. In our rows, it is the one customers choose for patios, courtyards and large containers.

Both are slow-growing, so patience is part of the deal. But if you're working with a modest lot or a tight corner, the size difference alone may settle the question in Crimson Queen's favor.

Growing Needs Compared

The two trees share nearly identical needs, so this table lists them side by side.

Factor Bloodgood Crimson Queen
USDA Zones 5–8 5–8
Light Full sun to part shade, with afternoon shade in hot climates Full sun to part shade, with afternoon shade in hot climates
Water Moderate, consistent moisture Moderate, consistent moisture
Soil Well-drained, rich loam, acid to neutral Well-drained, rich loam, acid to neutral
Drought Tolerance Moderate when established Moderate when established
Salt Tolerance Low Low
Mature Height 12–20 ft 8–12 ft
Mature Spread 15–20 ft 10–15 ft

The good news: both cultivars want the same basic growing conditions. They're both selections of Acer palmatum, so their cultural needs overlap almost completely. Neither tolerates salt, poor drainage, or prolonged drought without regular supplemental water once established. Both prefer slightly acidic, well-drained soil rich in organic matter.

The species is rated for zones 5a through 8b, and we would not push either tree past zone 8. Our hardiness zone guide covers the cold and warm limits in more detail.

Pros and Cons of Each

Here is how the two trees stack up in practice, starting with Bloodgood.

Bloodgood Japanese Maple

These are the points that count for and against the upright tree.

Pros:

  • Iconic upright form that works as a specimen tree or focal point
  • Bold palmate foliage creates strong visual impact
  • Holds deep red color exceptionally well through the growing season
  • Branches visible year-round add winter interest to the landscape
  • Easier to site near patios or walkways because the form is predictable and controllable
  • Does well in a large container while young, then moves to the ground
  • Minimal pruning required compared to some cultivars

Cons:

  • Requires more space at full maturity (12–20 ft in height, 15–20 ft in spread)
  • Not ideal for very small yards or tight urban lots
  • Less dramatic texture than finely dissected cultivars
  • Needs consistent water and well-drained soil, and is sensitive to girdling roots if planted too deep
  • Leaf scorch can occur in extreme heat, wind, or full sun in hot climates

Crimson Queen Japanese Maple

Now the same look at the weeping tree.

Pros:

  • Smaller mature size makes it perfect for modest gardens and containers
  • Weeping form is more ornamental and unusual than upright types
  • Finely cut foliage creates a delicate, sophisticated appearance
  • The graceful drooping branches can frame a vista or soften hardscape
  • Excellent for Japanese gardens, Zen landscapes, and Asian-inspired designs
  • Can be trained or limbed up to create an elegant small patio tree

Cons:

  • Weeping branches require more space horizontally than vertically, so it's not suitable for very narrow planting areas
  • The drooping form means lower branches may touch soil or mulch, increasing disease risk in wet conditions
  • More delicate appearance can look sparse compared to a full upright tree
  • Needs winter protection in the colder end of its range, especially when grown in a pot
  • Harder to find in the nursery trade than Bloodgood
  • More expensive when available

Which One We'd Plant

There's no "wrong" choice between these two. They're both outstanding trees that earn their place in ornamental gardens. The decision comes down to three things: your available space, your garden design style, and how much size you're comfortable managing.

If you have room for an upright specimen and you want bold, reliable deep red color from a tried-and-true cultivar, our pick is Bloodgood. It is the most versatile, the most available, and the most forgiving of the two. It works in conventional landscapes and stands out immediately.

If you're working with a smaller footprint or you want the sophistication of a weeping form with lacy foliage, Crimson Queen delivers a more refined aesthetic. It's also easier to accommodate in a container while young, which gives you flexibility if you're testing the site or planning ahead.

Choose Bloodgood if you want:

  • A focal point specimen tree with strong visual presence
  • Year-round architectural interest from visible branching
  • A tree that holds deep red color exceptionally well
  • A medium-sized tree for a conventional landscape layout
  • A reliable choice that's widely available and affordable
  • A container-friendly option when young
  • A tree to anchor a perennial border or mixed foundation planting

Choose Crimson Queen if you want:

  • A smaller, more delicate tree for a modest space
  • Ornamental, feathery foliage as the defining feature
  • A weeping form for a Japanese or Zen garden aesthetic
  • A tree that works well as a patio or courtyard focal point
  • The option to keep the tree in a large container for several years
  • A tree with more texture and movement in its branching
  • A specimen that commands attention for its unusual form, not just color

Quick Reference

This table sums up the differences between the two trees.

Attribute Bloodgood Crimson Queen
Form Upright, vase-shaped Weeping, mounding
Leaf Type Palmate, 5–7 lobes, bold Finely dissected, lacy
Foliage Color Deep reddish-purple to burgundy Deep reddish-purple to burgundy
Fall Color Crimson to bright red Crimson to bright red
Height at Maturity 12–20 ft 8–12 ft
Spread at Maturity 15–20 ft 10–15 ft
Growth Rate Slow to moderate Slow to moderate
Hardiness Zones 5–8 Zones 5–8
Light Needs Full sun to part shade Full sun to part shade
Best For Focal specimen, conventional gardens Small spaces, Zen gardens, containers
Availability Widely available, most affordable Less common, typically pricier

Choosing Between Bloodgood and Crimson Queen

Both are slow-growing, long-lived trees that reward consistent moisture, well-drained soil and a spot with afternoon shade. The choice comes down to space and shape. Bloodgood gives you a larger upright tree with dependable deep red color, and Crimson Queen gives you a smaller weeping tree with lacy leaves. Pick the one that fits the spot you actually have, not the one in the photo.

Bloodgood Japanese Maple nursery tree

Bloodgood Japanese Maple

Nursery-grown Bloodgood Japanese Maple in sizes from QT Container, shipped to your door.

From $49.49

Shop Now →

Customers come back to us for Bloodgood because the trees arrive well rooted and the color holds true to what they bought. We are growers with our own farms, and we grow and sell top-quality trees, shrubs and grasses.